Nine year old Mara asked soon to be ten year old Lucy, “Can you invite me to your birthday party?” Lucy responded, “I can’t because it is going to be at my beach house and it’s too far away for you.” Mara had a slightly disappointed face after hearing that response. Lucy went on to describe her upcoming party and what would take place. During an appropriate reciprocal language moment, when Lucy finished, Mara told about her upcoming birthday party, which was to happen in 5 days, and the impending events. Interestingly, Lucy just listened to Mara’s description and then the subject changed.
What a perfect opportunity for a social pragmatic language lesson. Clearly it was necessary for Mara to learn that it was not appropriate for her to request an invitation to someone’s party. Beyond that, though, she requested an invitation to Lucy’s party despite the fact that Mara was having her own party and did not invite Lucy. Mara felt no awkwardness about that. Not surprisingly, Lucy didn’t even pick up on it.
This made me think of all the times I told my sons, “It’s not polite to ask someone to invite you.” or “If you do not invite him, how will you feel if he has a party and doesn’t invite you?” or “Just because you invite someone it is not guarantee they will invite you.” It made me think of the time my son did invite a boy who lives around the corner to his party and the boy had a party two days later at his house, not inviting my son, only to be found out when we drove down his block to get to our house (which is the route we always take). My son was quite philosophical about it, “Maybe his Mom only let him have a certain number of kids.” My son’s mother was not so generous in her thoughts.
I can’t help but ask myself over and over, “Doesn’t anyone teach these children proper social behaviors?” My answer for the general population is “Sometimes I wonder.” My answer for the pragmatically impaired population is, “I will do my best to teach these things since each and every interaction may be a struggle.” If I can prepare Mara and Lucy for the challenges to come, I may not be able to save them some disappointment, but I can help them be prepared for their reactions and the reactions of others.
Activities involving exposure to appropriate and inappropriate things to say to others can set the stage for accomplishing this learning. I have collected quotes “out of the mouths of babes” and had children act them out. We have then categorized them into the famed “DO” and “DON’T” columns. To provide a twist in the activity, we sometimes say the same quote in different tones to see if it changes the meaning. As I compiled these quotes I realized how many of them are appropriate if used in another context. Some have been extracted from conversations where the original comment might have been quite appropriate, but alas, something was lost in the translation.
“You’re only 8 years old?”
“I used to have a shirt like that when I was a little kid.”
“Can you invite me to your birthday party?”
“I saw that movie, it was terrible.”
“If you keep eating junk you’ll get fat.”
“My hair gets messy too when I play.”
“You look better in long hair.”
“The Mets stink.”
“My Mom says the Cartoon Network is bad T.V.”
“My Dad calls my Mom stupid all the time.”
“You can have it if you say, “Please.”
“I don’t want to play any more.”
“Maybe we’ll do that next time.”
Another variation on this activity is to assign children with personality/emotion jobs or hats. I have made hats in the office out of crowns or caps and they are labeled, “MEAN”, “HURT”, “SORRY”, “ANGRY”, “SAD”, “BORED”, etc. If a child is wearing a particular hat they have to act out the quote in this way. It is a good way to see how different emotions can be conveyed with the same words. We then analyze the cues we received. Sometimes I secretly ask a child to say the quote in a particular way and the audience guesses the correct emotion, assigning the hat to the speaker. There are many ways to change up the activity and make it fun.
I have found that just listening to the conversation around me provides multiple opportunities for social pragmatic language lessons. Whether you overhear an adult conversation about gossip, or one person consoling another, ideas should pop into your head. Every time I hear children negotiating with one another I think of new activities. After my late day groups, the children who attend often stay and trade Pokemon cards in my waiting room because that activity is forbidden in the group room. Listening to these unfacilitated interactions is always food for thought. So take some time and listen.